Green New Deal? Murkowski says no, opts for middle way on climate

Sens. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, and Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., shown here at 2019 CERAWeek, are talking a lot about climate change. (Photo courtesy IHS Markit)

Sen. Lisa Murkowski is talking about global warming more than ever these days. While the Green New Deal is a lightning rod in Congress, Murkowski says she’s reaching for what’s politically possible.

Among the big goals included in the Green New Deal is to transition to energy sources with zero emissions, within a decade. Murkowski takes a more measured and less specific approach.

“We propose that we focus on these technologies that will allow us to get us to a lower carbon economy reduce our emissions but do so in a way that is responsible that is sensitive to the economy,” she said at a recent oil industry conference in Houston.

As chair of the Senate Energy Committee, Murkowski is a regular at the annual conference, known as CERAWeek. By her side this year was the new top Democrat on her committee: Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia.

He’s a champion of coal, and she’s a fan of more oil production. No one expected they would focus on climate change. But they have. It’s been a recurring theme in their hearings, and they co-authored a March 8 opinion piece in the Washington Post headlined “It’s time to act on climate change – responsibly.”

“I said, ‘Why don’t we put this out before CERAWeeek, so they know that this is real,'” Manchin recalled.

Murkowski seems comfortable talking about the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. At a recent hearing in her committee, she put up maps of Alaska and talked about the diminished sea ice and the thawing of permafrost.

“In Alaska, we view that there is no choice here,” she said. “In the Arctic we’re seeing warming at twice, over twice the average of the rest of the Lower 48.”

Manchin sounds like a senator still working to convince his constituents of the science, that manmade climate change is real.

“If you come from a red state such as West Virginia, a lot of people talk of climate change as being basically in Biblical terms. ‘It’s always changing and it will continue to change,'” Manchin said, outlining his counter-argument to that skepticism.

Like Murkowski, Manchin talks about developing new technologies to reduce carbon emissions, without drastically cutting back on fossil fuel production.

“We can do a lot more. But we have to use what we have,” he said. “We’re not going to eliminate. We’re going to innovate.”

Murkowski and Manchin talk about developing ways to capture carbon, as well as improving renewable energy and nuclear power. But some policymakers and many environmental groups say innovation alone won’t work fast enough to prevent catastrophic climate change. They say the U.S. has to limit or tax carbon.

Murkowski sees danger in moving too fast on climate.

“I appreciate the urgency. I understand that,” she said. “But I also recognize that that we have to work within the systems that we have and we need to make sure that we’re not destroying our economy at the same time that we’re trying to work toward a lower-carbon economy.”

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has promised a vote on the Green New Deal – not because he likes  it, but to force Democrats into an uncomfortable vote on an issue he considers a loser.

Murkowski says political pigeon-holing and finger-pointing on climate isn’t helpful. As she sees it, the debate about the Green New Deal distracts from the effort to find more pragmatic solutions.

Editor’s note: The feature photo’s caption has been updated with a more accurate attribution.